Auto-cancel builds for default branch
under review
E
Emil Ong
Originally asked here: https://discuss.circleci.com/t/auto-cancel-builds-on-default-branch/5536
We would like auto-cancel to apply to the default branch, specifically because we have a deploy action associated with it. The deploy is slow and multiple builds are often racing with each other and we occasionally get an older build that finishes after a newer one, leaving us with older code deployed. (This is only for a staging environment deploy in our case though.)
CCI-I-214
Minjun Seong
Hi folks, I'm a product manager at CircleCI. We have introduced the ability to control serial execution of jobs across your organization (https://circleci.com/docs/guides/orchestrate/controlling-serial-execution-across-your-organization/). We'd love your feedback on whether this addresses your concerns or if there are remaining limitations we should prioritize.
J
Jeff Fairley
Minjun Seong This is a great feature to have and maybe covers OP, but it doesn't address my need. For our default branches, we rerun all tests then release using semantic-release (https://semantic-release.gitbook.io). SR won't create a tag if the commit isn't HEAD, so all those test-run job minutes leading up to the release attempt are wasted effort (and $$) if another commit was already pushed. I would prefer the ongoing job on an old commit be aborted when a new commit comes in.
C
C-skahya@nexstar.tv
We definitely need these. Because of the slow deployment process we have in master, it may end up with older version to deploy to prod due to race conditions.
C
Cassandra Stone
Any updates here?
G
Github@georgekronberg.com
4 years? More like 6. The initial discussion thread happened in Aug 2016. It's not just a nice-to-have -- it's truly a critical feature, that is somehow still not in the product. If you merge 2 PRs one right after another, the earlier merge can take a few seconds longer to build and ultimately override a later merged build that is already in production.
Liya Ai
updated the status to
under review
Hi Everyone - just a quick update here, we know this is a highly requested feature request and our teams are actively evaluating how to improve this experience. Will post more updates as they come in, thanks!
Peter Sankauskas
4 years and we still have to do this silly work around because you insist on forcing your antiquated conventions on your customers.
D
Dave Sueltenfuss
This is a must have for my project!
E
Esa Nuurtamo
This is a must have feature!
I think this is a business choice that CircleCi made to make more money… It is ridiculous that I have to pay for these redundant builds for default branch that do not add any value to our testing process!
Liya Ai
Merged in a post:
Auto Cancelling a Redundant Build on Default branch
r
rraivil@caremessage.org
Have the possibility to configure a repository to auto cancel a redundant build on default branch, and not just feature branches.
CCI-I-1245
Y
Yann
You could also implement this workaround > https://discuss.circleci.com/t/auto-cancel-redundant-builds-on-the-default-branch/39468
Load More
→